Make the right call when you need insurance!

4281 Shelburne Rd, Shelburne, VT 05482

Open: Monday-Friday: 8am – 4:30pm

Phone: 802.985.2453

About Us

We’re located at 4281 Shelburne Road in Shelburne, Vermont.

From Webster Road, we’re ¼ mile headed North. Enter driveway for Dutch Mill Family Restaurant and take your first left.

When Lester Titus opened the doors in 1979, he knew Customer Service was an area of distinction and made it the cornerstone of the agency, a tradition continued by his daughter, Terrell Titus through her retirement in 2015.

This superior customer service continuously draws new customers to our family of valued customers as Annette Hannah maintains a high standard where Customer Satisfaction is the Rule, Not the Exception! 

No agency can be successful without quality companies to represent. We are especially pleased to represent the Co-operative Insurance Companies of Middlebury, VT and their subsidiary UI Insurance Services, Inc.

Our dedicated, local agents are Vermonters with decades of experience in the industry.  We are your neighbors so we know what you’re up against.

This winning combination of service and representation enables us to provide you with an extensive array of high quality insurance products.

Insurance We Offer

Homeowners
Mobilehome
Farms
Automobile
Recreational vehicles
Boats
Business Owners
Commercial
Workers Compensation
Professional Liability

Our Team

Annette Hannah, CPIW

Annette has a vast array of experience with personal insurance and commercial insurance with a focus in workers compensation. Annette has been in the insurance industry since 1985. Annette purchased Titus Insurance Agency from Terrell Titus in 2015. Titus Insurance was built on strong customer service and Annette is committed to this tradition. Annette is a native Vermonter, married with 2 children, and is dedicated to helping you get the best coverage for the best rates.

Jill McCaffrey

Jill McCaffrey, CISR

Jill has been with the agency since 1998, with a focus in personal lines. She has a long background of exceptional customer service, in fields ranging from retail and banking, to health and day care providing. She takes pride in the attention she gives to our client’s needs, and provides assistance in educating our clients, so they feel confident about their insurance choices.

Jill is a graduate of Trinity College, and has been a longtime resident of South Burlington, where she and her husband have raised their five boys.

Donna Wagner

Donna Wagner

Donna Wagner has almost 40 years of personal lines insurance experience.  In her spare time she enjoys spending time with her daughter Renae and grandsons Austin and Dylan, riding UTV, making wreaths and watching NASCAR. 

She lives in Richmond with her husband Bruce and their cat Tommy. 

Nancy Danforth

Nancy Danforth

Nancy Danforth joined Titus Insurance Agency in March 2017.  She has worked in the insurance industry for over 30 years. Nancy began her career as a personal lines agent and over the last 15 years has worked as a commercial account manager. She has managed all lines of insurance in the small and middle market arenas with industry emphasis on technology, medical, real estate and manufacturing.

Nancy is a member of The Champlain Valley Association of Insurance Professionals, serving in a variety of capacities, having served as the President of the association in 2000 and 2007.

Nancy graduated from Trinity College with a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration.

Nancy lives with her wife Beth, “Ben” and “Fenway” in Milton. They enjoy traveling and spending time with their animals.

Roger Johnson

Roger Johnson

Roger is a details-oriented individual that joined the Titus team in late 2016. Roger has his roots in accounting, but after making the transition to insurance he hasn’t looked back.

He is a native Vermonter and has found himself living in Chittenden county enjoying everything that the community has to offer. Roger is proficient in both commercial and personal lines and looks forward to speaking to you about your insurance needs!

Aaron Conner

Aaron, a native Michigander, decided in 2010 to move and explore the opportunities Vermont had to offer.  With a background in Life and Health insurance making the transition to Property and Casualty came naturally.  Aaron has worked in both commercial and personal lines insurance over the last ten years, and came to realize his enjoyment in the insurance industry is derived from helping provide the appropriate balance between cost and coverage for individuals and their families.

He currently resides in Burlington Vermont.

Aaron joined Titus Insurance in February of 2020.

Covid-19 Protocols In EffectOur office has new procedures to keep you safe.

We are fully staffed to serve you! 

Prior to visiting the office we ask that you contact your Agent by phone or email to schedule an appointment.

Thank you for your patience as we work to keep our staff, customers, and community safe.

For general questions or customer service, call 802.985.2453.